Afternoon BriefAI Search & Discovery

Organic CTR on AI Overview Queries Fell 61% in Seer's Data — 5 Moves CMOs Should Make Now

Seer Interactive tracked organic CTR on informational queries with AI Overviews falling 61% (June 2024 to September 2025), then recovering in early 2026. Here are 5 moves CMOs should make to recalibrate attribution.

Christian Lehman
Christian LehmanMay 17, 2026

Seer Interactive's September 2025 update tracked 3,119 informational search terms across 42 client organizations from June 2024 through September 2025. Organic CTR on queries where an AI Overview appeared fell from 1.76% in June 2024 to 0.61% in September 2025; Seer's page labels this an overall decline of 61% and says organic CTR on those queries was cut by nearly two-thirds. Seer's April 2026 update, covering 53 brands and 5.47 million tracked queries from January 2025 through February 2026, found that the 2025 decline did not extend into 2026: organic CTR on AI Overview queries climbed from a 1.3% floor in December 2025 to 2.4% in February 2026, and Seer says two months of data is not a basis for forecasting recovery. Either way, organic sessions capture less of the buyer's path than they used to. The move is to earn citations inside AI answers and track the branded and direct demand that may follow.

Why Informational Organic CTR Fell on AI Overview Queries

Researchers at the Indian School of Business and Carnegie Mellon University posted a randomized field experiment on AI Overviews to SSRN in April 2026. As Search Engine Journal summarizes it, 1,065 US desktop Chrome users recruited on Prolific were randomly assigned to see or not see AI Overviews for two weeks in January and February 2026. Removing AI Overviews raised outbound clicks from 0.38 to 0.61 per search: a 38% reduction in organic clicks on queries where AI Overviews appeared, with zero-click searches rising from 54% to 72%. Self-reported search satisfaction was nearly identical with and without AI Overviews, so the experiment found no measurable user-experience gain to offset the lost clicks. It is a randomized test of what earlier correlational studies had suggested, on active desktop Chrome users rather than all Google users.

Ahrefs' February 2026 update found the same direction at scale: across 300,000 keywords (December 2025 against December 2023, Search Console data), an AI Overview's presence correlates with a 58% lower average CTR for the top-ranking page, up from the 34.5% Ahrefs reported in April 2025. A Pew Research study of 68,000 real queries found users clicked just 8% of the time when AI summaries were present versus 15% without — a 46.7% relative reduction.

None of these studies measures the branded half of the story. Seer's CTR data is cut by query type and by whether a brand was cited; it does not follow a person from an AI citation to a later branded search. One plausible reading is that AI Overviews handle the informational query, the user sees your name in the answer, and some of them come back later with a branded search that your content attribution never connects to the original answer. That is a hypothesis you can test in your own Search Console data (move 2 below), not something these studies show.

The Attribution Gap This Creates

Falling clicks create a measurement problem for the channels that feed pipeline. Similarweb data shows zero-click searches for news-related queries jumping from 56% to 69% between May 2024 and May 2025. Bain & Company's survey found that about 80% of consumers rely on zero-click results in at least 40% of their searches.

When a buyer asks ChatGPT or Perplexity for a recommendation, sees your brand cited, then searches your name on Google two days later, GA4 credits "branded organic" or "direct." The AI interaction that may have created purchase intent receives zero attribution.

If you are cutting content or earned media because GA4 says organic is declining, you may be defunding the work that puts your name in front of buyers before they search for it.

5 Moves to Make in the Next 90 Days

1. Track AI citation share on your top 20 commercial queries

Run your highest-intent category and comparison queries through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Mode. Log whether your brand is cited, mentioned, or absent. Do this weekly. This is now a primary KPI, not a nice-to-have. In Seer's April 2026 update, being cited in an AI Overview came with 120% more organic clicks per impression than not being cited, though still 38% below queries with no AI Overview. Seer's September 2025 update notes it cannot prove that citation causes the higher CTR, since stronger brands may simply be cited more often. Citation status belongs on the dashboard next to ranking position.

2. Correlate branded search lift with content and earned media launches

Pull branded query impressions from Google Search Console monthly. Overlay them against your content calendar, press hits, and distribution dates. If branded impressions spike after a major article or media placement, that is consistent with Machine Relations at work — AI-mediated influence showing up as branded demand rather than referral traffic — though a correlation like this needs ruling out seasonality and other campaigns before you call it proof. Track the pattern across a 30–60 day window, not a 7-day attribution window that misses the entire AI influence cycle.

3. Add self-reported attribution to every lead form

Add one open-text field: "How did you first hear about us?" No dropdown — open text captures answers like "ChatGPT recommended you" or "I kept seeing your name in AI search." This is the single most useful measurement change you can make for AI-influenced pipeline. Target 60%+ response rates by making the field required. If your sales team is hearing "I asked the AI and it recommended you," that signal needs to be systematized, not anecdotal.

4. Restructure content investment toward citation-eligible assets

The GEO paper (Aggarwal et al., accepted to KDD 2024) tested content-optimization methods on its GEO-bench benchmark and found they can boost visibility in generative engine responses by up to 40%, with the effect varying by domain. Stop producing thin informational posts that AI Overviews will summarize and discard. Invest in original data, comparison frameworks, and source architecture — the structured evidence that makes a page worth citing rather than summarizing. A citation can put your name in front of buyers who never click; whether that comes back as branded search is what move 2 tests.

5. Recalibrate channel budgets using the signals last-click cannot see

Do not cut organic, content, or earned media because last-click attribution shows declining sessions. Before moving budget, compare branded search trends, self-reported attribution data, and AI citation rates against channel spend, so the decision rests on the signals last-click attribution cannot see.

What This Means for Machine Relations Strategy

The CTR data above fits the idea that AI visibility compounds through citation rather than clicks, but it is consistent with that reading, not proof of it. An AI citation may show up later as a branded search, a direct visit, or a sales call where the buyer already knows who you are. Moves 2 and 3 are how you find out.

Google's own Q1 2026 earnings tell the same story: $60.4 billion in Google Search & other revenue, up 19% year over year, while Google Network revenue (the product that monetizes publisher inventory) was $6.97 billion against $7.26 billion a year earlier. That is consistent with more value staying on Google's own results and less flowing out to publisher inventory. The platform economics work. The old click-based measurement model does not.

CMOs who adapt fastest will stop treating attribution decay as a mystery and start treating it as a source-visibility problem. Build the citation layer, track branded demand as the conversion signal, and recalibrate spend before the quarterly review reveals a gap you cannot explain.

FAQ

Does lower organic CTR mean SEO is dead? No. It means informational SEO alone is structurally weaker. Commercial-intent queries and branded queries still convert. In the ISB/CMU experiment, per Search Engine Journal's summary, sponsored clicks and search frequency stayed steady while organic clicks fell. SEO is not dead — the measurement surface shifted.

How do I know if AI search is driving my branded traffic? Correlate AI citation frequency with branded search volume over 30–60 day windows. If branded impressions rise after content launches or earned media placements without a corresponding paid campaign, AI-mediated discovery is one possible explanation; rule out seasonality, PR and other campaigns before attributing it.

What tools track AI citation share? BrightEdge, Semrush, Profound, and Otterly.ai all offer AI citation monitoring. A rotating prompt harness across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude with weekly logging works for teams without enterprise tooling. The signal matters more than the tool.